Porsche Taycan EV Forum banner

1 - 6 of 6 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
446 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Expect Porsche Taycan reliability rankings to exceed what we're used to with the 911, Panamera, Cayenne and Macan.

Why? Because an obvious benefit of it being all-electric, aside from unmatched performance, is reliability thanks to less complex moving parts. As Porsche releases more information on the Taycan's powertrain and drivetrain i'll be interested in where its weak points might be. It's the first of many EV's to come from them and won't be perfect an like any completely new vehicle. They all have bugs that need to be worked out...

FORTUNATELY Porsche has been vocal about it saying the following to a German publication:
  • “A central question in the development was: Where is the optimal balance between range and performance? Theoretically, one would have to pack only a correspondingly large battery in the vehicle to get a lot of range. But that would not be typical Porsche, if only because of the excessive weight. Instead, we use very light electric motors. In addition, we can achieve a range of 500 kilometers via the high power density and high efficiency of the electric drive. This results in low power consumption, so we can use smaller and lighter batteries.”
  • “With Taycan we provide two measures for consistent performance in all driving situations. On the one hand, we opted for the choice of electric motors with permanent-magnet synchronous machines, which enable high continuous power and thus ensure reproducible performance. This means that they can accelerate not just once but several times in a row. The same applies to driving at a constant high speed. On the other hand, we have developed an intelligent cooling system that prevents potential power losses due to excessive heat generation by always delivering cooling power exactly to those components that you need.”
Those quotes may not speak directly to the Porsche Taycan's reliability but it will be partially derived from the 'consistent performance in all driving situations'. Existing Porsche models do well already, so well that Porsche's dependability/reliability ranking in the latest J.D. Power 2019 study placed it pole position with Lexus and Toyota, beating Toyota :grin:

Tesla refuses to participate in J.D. Power studies probably because the results would be bad for PR. A Consumer Reports ranking of reliability base on owner feedback puts Tesla at #27 while Porsche is at #11. :plain:

One area of concern are A3 e-Tron charging problems (Audi is owned by VW Group that also owns Porsche). Owners had charging issues since 2017, some not as much as others and hopefully by now its been worked out. Charging issues might show up in the e-Tron SUV but slow sales due to battery supply issues mean less examples for us to learn from.

Porsche's reputation is on the line and getting the Taycan right will be critical to Porsche success in the EV landscape. I'll be paying attention to how things play out with the new e-Tron SUV. Taycan delivery timeline falls too close to the e-Tron SUV which leads me to believe we'll see common problems among them.


 

·
Registered
Joined
·
59 Posts
Never realized how well Porsche ranked looking at JD's report. My expectations were lower than what the CR study gathered.

I think these Taycans have the potential to push Porsche even closer to Lexus.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
32 Posts
You need to look at the initial quality: (not sure why all my uploads always end up as thumbnails you have to click on)
The Korean carmakers obviously have by far the best manufacturing quality control systems, followed by Porsche. Lexus/Toyota is not that great, although on the long run, the Japanese cars do well on reliability
 

Attachments

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
302 Posts
You need to look at the initial quality: (not sure why all my uploads always end up as thumbnails you have to click on)
The Korean carmakers obviously have by far the best manufacturing quality control systems, followed by Porsche. Lexus/Toyota is not that great, although on the long run, the Japanese cars do well on reliability


I think most of the initial quality issues really just come down to people griping about infotainment issues, etc.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
32 Posts
I think most of the initial quality issues really just come down to people griping about infotainment issues, etc.
I was reading about complaints of the JD Power system. It definitely is not the best, as you are right. If someone doesn't like how a system is or dont know how to figure out how to use it, they can list it as a problem. But the most important survey is actually customer satisfaction

I know its old, but you have to pay for Consumer Reports, so i cant get the latest.....or haven't found it
"To determine owner satisfaction, Consumer Reports asked "Would you buy it again?" of subscribers to its website and magazine, who own about 500,000 vehicles, of the 2015 to 2018 model years. Respondents to the Owner Satisfaction Survey also rated their vehicles in six categories: driving experience, comfort, value, styling, audio and climate systems."

1. Tesla (90)
2. Porsche (85)
3. Genesis (81)
4. Chrysler (78)
5. Audi (76)
6. Mazda (76)
7. Subaru (76)
8. Toyota (76)
9. Honda (75)
10. Lincoln (75)
11. Mini (73)
12. Ram (73
13. Kia (72)
14. Chevrolet (72)
15. BMW (72)
16. GMC (72)
17. Ford (70)
18. Lexus (70)
19. Volvo (69)
20. Dodge (68)
21. Jeep (68)
22. Mercedes-Benz (67)
23. Volkswagen (67)
24. Hyundai (67)
25. Buick (66)
26. Cadillac (64)
27. Infiniti (60)
28. Mitsubishi (58)
29. Nissan (58)
30. Acura (58)

And the Taycan will be my 6th Porsche.....customer satisfaction converts to brand loyalty
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
260 Posts
If you were to ask me where I would rank Porsche on this list, I would've guessed that they were in the middle of the pack.

I think it's very promising for the Taycan and shows that Porsche isn't going to mess around with their first performance EV and leave people unsatisfied.
 
1 - 6 of 6 Posts
Top